When a Post Goes Too Far: Understanding School Threat Laws in Florida

Florida School Threat Accusations: What Parents Need to Know Right Now

Raising teenagers today is a very different experience from what most of us lived through. Their friendships are online, their arguments are online, and unfortunately, so are their impulsive moments. A frustrated comment in a group chat or a joke meant for two friends can be screenshotted, shared, misinterpreted, and suddenly treated as a serious threat.

When parents call me about these situations, I can hear the fear behind the words, not just fear of “legal trouble,” but fear of what this says about who their child is becoming. I understand that feeling. Professionally, I’ve handled many of these cases. Personally, I’ve lived through my own share of late-night conversations and moments where you suddenly realize just how fast teenagers can find themselves in deeper water than they ever meant to be in.

So let’s take a breath and walk through what’s actually happening in these cases, why they escalate so quickly, and what you need to know to protect your child and help them through it.

The Gap Between Teen Intent and Florida Law

When a teenager says, “I was just joking,” they usually are. Teen humor is dramatic, sarcastic, dark, and influenced by every corner of the internet. But Florida’s school threat laws are not built around teenage language. They’re built around safety, prevention, and worst-case scenarios.

Under Florida Statute § 836.10, a threat doesn’t have to be:

  • Meant seriously
  • Possible to carry out
  • Directed at someone specific
  • Public
  • Or even written by the student (reposts count)

If someone could reasonably interpret the message as threatening, the law applies.

I’m not telling you this to scare you. I’m telling you because most parents assume the opposite. They assume that a “joke” will be treated like a joke. That’s not how these cases are evaluated, and it’s one of the reasons families feel blindsided.

There’s No Real “Buffer” for Teens on Social Media

A teenager posts something on Snapchat believing it will disappear. Then another student takes a screenshot of that post and shares it. Another student shows a teacher the image of the screenshot. The teacher contacts the Security Resource Officer. Suddenly a message your child barely remembers typing is being interpreted in the worst possible light.

This is the reality of today’s school safety climate:

Schools must respond quickly, even if no one believes your child intended harm. From the school’s perspective, hesitation is a liability. Of course from a parent’s perspective, it feels like everything is happening too fast.

This is where I see most families start to panic, not because they think their child is dangerous, but because the situation seems completely out of proportion to the child they know at home.

School Responses Move in Minutes, Not Days

Most parents expect the school to take its time when something like this comes up, ask a few questions, gather the facts, and then reach out. But the reality is usually much faster and more abrupt. Once a message is flagged, administrators move quickly. Your child may be pulled out of class and questioned before you even know anything is happening. The School Resource Officer is often brought in early, and by the time you get a call, you’re hearing terms like “threat assessment” or “safety protocol,” which understandably raise everyone’s anxiety.

By the time you arrive, your child may already feel overwhelmed. They’ve probably tried to explain themselves to several adults who are required to treat every word literally and according to strict procedures. None of this means your child is a criminal or a danger to anyone. It simply reflects a system that prioritizes caution first and context later.

For parents, the important thing is to step in early, not because the situation is hopeless, but because the first stage is where you can make the biggest difference in how things play out.

What I Tell Parents in Those First Stressful Hours

When something like this happens, most teenagers instinctively try to talk their way out of it. They explain, backtrack, get defensive, or say more than they should. This isn’t because they’re trying to hide anything, but because they’re scared and trying to fix the situation on their own. Unfortunately, that usually ends up muddying the waters.

Your job isn’t to cross-examine your child or make them relive the moment. Your job is simply to steady things so the adults involved can get a clear picture of what actually happened.

My job, if we end up working together, is to step in early and make sure the process doesn’t outrun the facts. A kid who was venting, joking, or reacting in the moment shouldn’t be treated the same way as someone who intended harm, and the sooner that distinction is clear, the smoother everything goes.

A lot of these cases can be resolved without formal charges. Many students qualify for diversion or school-based solutions. Counseling, behavior plans, and agreements are common outcomes. But those results don’t just fall into place automatically—they happen when someone steps in early enough to guide the situation before it gains momentum in the wrong direction.

Protecting Your Child’s Future Matters More Than One Mistake

Teenagers make mistakes. All of them. Some of those mistakes happen online, where the impact can be bigger than they ever intended. But even if the school reacted strongly, one message isn’t the whole story of who your child is or who they’re becoming. They’re still learning, still figuring themselves out, and still allowed to move forward with their lives.

And you’re allowed to feel everything at once—worry, frustration, disappointment, protectiveness. That’s part of being a parent, especially when something catches you off guard.

My role is to help take some of the weight off your shoulders. I’m here to make sure this situation is understood in context, that it doesn’t define your child, and that the people involved see more than one moment pulled from a phone screen.

If your child is being investigated for a threat or a post that was taken the wrong way, you don’t have to handle this on your own. These cases can move quickly, and having a clear, steady response early on can make a real difference. If you want to talk through what’s happening or figure out the next steps, feel free to reach out. I’m here to help you protect your child’s future.

Contact Donovan & Melendez Today